🎩 Inside the Mind of a Modern Originalist:
Constitutional Originalism: (noun, also known as “Weekend at Bernie’s Constitutionalism”) – puppeteering the dead to justify the present-day oppression they’re too cowardly to name.
1. “I’m a bigot.”
You don’t believe in racial equity, gender parity, LGBTQ rights, or immigrant dignity. You believe in natural hierarchies, with you near the top.
2. “I like bigoted rulings.”
You get misty-eyed for Plessy v. Ferguson, nostalgic for Lochner, and bitter that Brown or Roe ever existed. The rulings you like are about preserving order, not justice.
3. “I hate egalitarian laws.”
You despise the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act, and Title IX. You view the New Deal and Great Society as aberrations from the Constitution’s “true vision.”
4. “I can’t say that aloud.”
Because you’d lose elections. Because even your own suburban base doesn’t want to say out loud, “Black people should sit at the back of the bus.”
5. “But everyone loves the Founding Fathers.”
Ah-ha! The cheat code. Wrap your vision in constitutional cosplay. Suddenly, oppression becomes “fidelity to the Framers.”
6. “And those Founders were white men.”
Which conveniently matches your preferred power structure. Patriarchy, property rights, racial hierarchy? All built-in.
7. “And their biases match mine!”
Jefferson owned slaves. Adams hated democracy. Hamilton wanted an elite ruling class. Madison feared the mob. They agree with me!
8. “So let’s prop them up like puppets.”
Just like Weekend at Bernie’s: they’re dead, but they’re dancing. You jam your hand up Madison’s corpse and have him explain why assault rifles are protected but abortion isn’t. You make Hamilton whisper that corporate speech is sacred and voting rights are not.
🧠 The Grift of “Original Meaning”
Modern originalism is not about text or history. It’s about ventriloquism—taking the cold bodies of 18th-century aristocrats and making them say:
- “Black voters? States’ rights.”
- “Gun control? Tyranny.”
- “Trans rights? Not in the parchment.”
And when challenged, you don’t justify your values. You say:
“Hey, don’t shoot the messenger—I’m just channeling James Madison.”
⚖️ Final Verdict
Originalism, as practiced today, is a reactionary ideology in costume.
It is not serious constitutional interpretation.
It is moral cowardice wrapped in tri-corner hats.
It is political revanchism rebranded as legal scholarship.
It is a corpse dragged through the court, grinning and waving, while liberty bleeds out offstage.
So yes: the big reveal isn’t a twist ending.
It’s a confession—and the robes no longer hide the rot.